Signings - Hit or Miss

many fans have slated the clubs signings over the last 12 months however are they really that bad ? I personally think we are now seeing that the data does work!

mullins - Hit

CBM- Hit

Casey - Hit

Tilley- miss

Henderson - hit

Taylor - miss

moore - n/a

Fink - miss but will be a hit

MVS - miss but will be a hit

Allen- hit

Lowry- Miss ?

Westergaard- Miss

Junior- hit

Anders - hit

Huggins - miss

Mcneilley- miss

Abbott - hit

Woodrow- miss

Berry - miss

imo many more hits than misses , lets trust the transfer strategy and hopefully Duff can further improve and get Morley, Humphries through the door in this window!

You’ve listed more misses than hits

2 Likes

some are on the fence , all in all, apart from Berry how many big misses are there? Connor Taylor i do think will come good as has all the attributes

Connor Taylor has great height and used that attribute to good effect yesterday but what are the other attributes that you have identified?

How important do you think it is for Michael Duff to have the final word on each recruitment decision.

1 Like

as you say , he is tall and has improved in the air (guidance from Duff i am sure ) he is good with the ball (ask BR fans) he is just low on confidence, once this improves i am sure we will see this)

What is the average for signings to be a hit anyway. Not every signing works out, for various reasons. We’ve made some poor transfers in most windows.

2 Likes

Connor Taylor has all the attributes…I think not!!

2 Likes

Woodrow splits the fanbase but on balance he’s been a ‘hit’ for me. Huggins I agree hasn’t shown much (injuries, etc) but may well be a hit if he successfully covers for Grimmer in his absence.

1 Like

Surely it’s a fundamental attribute of any self respecting professional footballer to be “good with the ball”. In what particular respect do you think Connor Taylor has displayed shortcomings (whilst with us but not with Bristol Rovers) when in possession of the ball?

based on his time at BR he was very good with the ball, granted not shown it here but personally with time think it will come, he also needs to work on upper body strength, if I was him, would start working out with Casey!

the club would not have invested so much if they did not see it

So, in short, you are confident that Connor Taylor has the potential to become an automatic choice for inclusion in the starting eleven. He certainly has age on his side and there can be few better mentors than someone who spent the entirety of his playing career as a very accomplished central defender.

Good to hear you being both positive and constructive.

1 Like

I (was) a secret Connor Taylor fan. I would love him to succeed. My secret is now public.

Huggins still an unknown, but his last two performances were great and he’ll be stepping into Grimmer’s shoes now I imagine depending on whether Duff wants to change shape or not.

Huggins and Taylor, and I suspect the likes of Tilley are others as well would have been developing under Duff’s management in training each and every week. Yes Connor has had some howlers, but I don’t think many of our squad escape from that tag this season.

Woodrow has been great. It’s the small things he does that probably don’t get noticed. His final contribution to the game yesterday where he took the ball after we were under pressure, move beyond the halfway line, and smacked it against a Wimbledon player to win the throw. I think his contributions, outside of his four goals and 1 assist are underrated by some here.

With regards to Berry, well, I guess the data doesn’t cover attitude. I remember Taff’s video on our new training ground building and Berry was in it for 30 seconds. He had a face like a slapped bottom.

2 Likes

Odd that someone described Taylor as ‘like a newly born giraffe’ and frankly I’m not sure he was wrong. Funny how revisionist things get after a morale boosting home win huh?

2 Likes

He always looked like he was in the middle of shitting himself, he’s the worlds most nervous man. He played well yesterday but that hasn’t really changed my opinion

3 Likes

Just look at the likes for Michael Duberry and how wrong we got that

While I think Connor Taylor could become good in the future, on the current form of those defenders in possession of starting places (Anders, Casey & Allen), he has a very long way to go. If one of them get suspended and/or injured, he HAS to take that opportunity. Otherwise, he’ll just be given a title of “He might have potential if he shows it”

Huggins impressed me at Wigan earlier in the season. He’s very skilful but lightweight for a defender.

No not really. My posting of Connor has been consistent of my above post.

Even ladt season we signed Bakinson and Bishop, both were misses. When was Hartridge?

And weve made some more bad signings on top of that. It happens. I had high hopes for John Williams in my youth.

No club gets all transfers bang on.

4 Likes